Cookie pricing starts at 54.00 per dozen. Prices vary based on the size, amount of colors, and complexity of the design. (average cookie size is 3.5"- 4" inches). Custom cookies is a very labor-intensive process because every detail is made by hand from start to finish. There are many steps to creating them which includes: making fresh dough for every order, mixing icing colors, rolling, cutting, baking, decorating, and packaging cookies. Please refer to the FAQ's tab for information.
Mini cookies are also available (mini cookies are 2"-2.5" inches in size) - pricing starts at $24.00 per dozen.
Character cookie pricing starts at $66.00 per dozen. Prices vary based on the number of characters included in each cookie set.
Basic: 1-2 colors simple design, minimum details
Detailed: 3-5 colors, simple details
Elaborate: 6 or more colors, several piped details, edible lace, gold or silver metallics, fondant accents, airbrushing, or hand-painted designs.
Additional Flavors: Chocolate, Chocolate Chip, Seasonal flavors: Pumpkin Spice, Spiced Apple, Cinnamon Roll, Snickerdoodle, Mint Chocolate Chip, and Pecan Pie may cost an additional fee starting from +$2.50- $4.00 per dozen.
Invoices are sent via email, and there is 24-hour payment policy before cancellation, for local pick-ups 50 % deposit is required. Deposits are non-refundable, and final payments are due one week before the event date. All shipped cookies MUST be paid in full prior to shipping. All payments can be made
via Square and all major credit cards are accepted. All custom cookies are final there are NO REFUNDS.
All shipments are sent via USPS Priority Mail and typically take 1-3 days to arrive depending on your location. Shipping cost range between $15.00-$30.00, (1-3 dozen cookies per box) and will arrive 1-2 days prior to your event date to ensure freshness. All orders are carefully packed to ensure your cookies will arrive intact; however, I cannot guarantee handling once an order is in the care of USPS. The New York Cookie Boutique is not responsible for errors made the Postal Service ( this includes: damages, loss packages, and delays).